| Name | Years of Service | |
| Clarence Smith | 1926/27-1934/35 |  |
| David Becker | 1935/36 |  |
| Charles Emlet | 1936/37 |  |
| Myrna King | 1937/38-1938/39 |  |
| Henry Remsburg | 1939/40-1941/42 |  |
| Henry Nelson | 1942/43-1944/45 |  |
| Pearl Garbrick (In February 1945 Mr. Nelson leaves for military service.) |
1945-1945/46 |  |
| Henry Nelson | 1946/47- 1954/55 |  |
| Hans Uberseder | 1955/56 – 1961/62 |  |
| Clyde Barr | 1962/63 – 1976/77 |  |
| Interviews with Clyde and Lyn Barr: http://gardnerlibrary.org/stories/clyde-barr http://gardnerlibrary.org/stories/lyn-barrIn remembrance of Clyde Barr: https://carlislehighschoolband.org/band-history/band-directors/mr-clyde-barr/ |
||
| Craig Sunday | 1977/78 – 1981/82 |  |
| David Rohrer | 1982/83 – 2011/2012 |  |
| Byron Mikesell | 2012/13 – October 2023 |  |
Carlisle High School Band 